In Vitro Skin Corrosion: Determining Corrosivity Without Animal Testing Using the RhE and TER Methods

Skin corrosion is the irreversible damage caused to the epidermis and dermis as a result of a substance coming into contact with the skin. This damage results in chemical burns, tissue necrosis, ulceration, and scar formation. Corrosive substances classified in the highest hazard category according to GHS (Globally Harmonized System) criteria pose an unacceptable risk to user safety. In the past, corrosion assessment was conducted exclusively through in vivo animal testing (OECD TG 404); today, however, in vitro methods validated in accordance with the 3R principles have become the primary testing approach. The two key tools driving this transition are the OECD TG 431 (RhE) and OECD TG 430 (TER) guidelines.

These two in vitro methods accounted for the vast majority of the corrosion studies we have conducted in our laboratory over the past three years. During this process, we observed that both tests possess high predictive power, but there are some practical challenges and critical points that require attention. In this article, in vitro we will share the scientific basis of the skin corrosion test, the application process of the RhE and TER methods, and our laboratory’s field experience.

The Scientific Basis of Skin Corrosion and a Stepwise Testing Strategy

Skin corrosion occurs when a chemical substance damages the skin barrier, leading to tissue damage. Corrosive substances are typically strong acids (pH ≤2) or strong bases (pH ≥11.5); they denature skin proteins, dissolve the lipid barrier, and disrupt cell membranes. However, pH value alone is not sufficient to determine corrosion potential; some substances can exhibit strong corrosive effects even at neutral pH. Therefore, validated biological test methods are required for corrosion assessment.

The OECD recommends a stepwise testing strategy for corrosion assessment. In the first step, existing data, pH measurements, and structure-activity relationship analyses are evaluated. Substances with a pH ≤ 2 or ≥ 11.5 are directly classified as “Skin Corrosive” (Category 1), and an in vitro test is not required. This approach prevents unnecessary testing and makes efficient use of resources. In the second stage, TG 430 or TG 431 in vitro tests are conducted. If these tests indicate that the substance is corrosive, in vivo testing is not required. If the test results are negative (the substance is not corrosive), OECD TG 439 (RhE irritation test) is performed to assess irritation potential.

We meticulously apply this stepwise strategy in our laboratory. Case study: A manufacturer of industrial cleaning products requested that we evaluate the corrosive potential of its new formulation. In the first step, we measured the pH; the pH value was 12.8. This was sufficient for a direct “Skin Corrosive” (Category 1) classification, and an in vitro test was not required. We informed the client that the GHS05 pictogram and the statement H314 (“Causes severe skin burns and eye damage”) must be used on the product’s packaging. This case is valuable in demonstrating how effective the stepwise strategy is.

OECD TG 431: Reconstituted Human Epidermis (RhE) Corrosion Test

OECD TG 431 is an in vitro test guideline based on reconstituted human epidermis (RhE) models used to assess the skin corrosion potential of chemical substances. Under TG 431, the corrosive potential of the test substance is evaluated using validated RhE models (EpiSkin™, EpiDerm™, SkinEthic™ RHE, LabCyte EPI-MODEL24, etc.). These models are three-dimensional tissue cultures derived from human keratinocytes that preserve the multilayered structure of the epidermal layer, the lipid barrier, and metabolic activity.

The basic principle of the TG 431 test is to apply the test substance to the RhE tissue for a specific period of time (typically 3 minutes or 1 hour) and then measure cell viability using the MTT assay. The MTT assay is based on the principle that MTT tetrazolium salt is reduced by mitochondrial dehydrogenase enzymes in living cells, converting it into purple-colored formazan crystals. The formazan crystals are dissolved in a suitable solvent and measured spectrophotometrically. The percentage of cell viability is calculated by comparison with a negative control; if viability is below 50 percent, the substance is classified as “corrosive.”

The most common challenge we face when performing the TG 431 test in our laboratory is ensuring uniform application of the test substance to the tissue. Especially with viscous or paste-like substances, achieving even distribution across the tissue surface can be difficult; this can lead to false-negative results. In such cases, we dilute the test substance in a suitable carrier before application or extend the application time. Additionally, some test substances (e.g., strongly colored substances) may interfere with the MTT assay; in such cases, we prepare appropriate blank controls. Case example: Upon suspicion of MTT interference in a dark-colored paint raw material, we verified cell viability using the NRU assay and obtained the correct result.

OECD TG 430: Transcutaneous Electrical Resistance (TER) Corrosion Test

OECD TG 430 is another in vitro test guideline used to evaluate the skin corrosion potential of chemical substances. TG 430 is a test conducted using ex vivo bovine or human skin, and its basic principle involves measuring the effect of the test substance on the electrical resistance (Transcutaneous Electrical Resistance – TER) of skin samples. Corrosive substances damage the skin barrier, thereby reducing electrical resistance; this decrease is an indicator of the substance’s corrosive potential.

In the TG 430 test, skin samples are placed in a two-compartment diffusion cell, and the test substance is applied to one surface of the skin. The electrical current passing through the skin is measured via electrodes, and the resistance value is calculated. If the resistance value falls below a specific threshold after the test substance is applied, the substance is classified as “corrosive.” The TG 430 is particularly suitable for water-soluble substances and substances with pH values at extreme ends of the spectrum.

The most common challenge we face when using the TG 430 in our laboratory is obtaining fresh leather samples. Cowhide is sourced from the slaughterhouse and must be used within the first 24 hours after slaughter, which requires logistical coordination. Furthermore, the integrity of the skin samples is critical for the reliability of the resistance measurement; damaged or dried-out skin samples can yield incorrect results. For this reason, we verify the integrity of the skin samples visually and electrically before each test. A case example: While conducting the TG 430 test on a pesticide active ingredient, the resistance value came out unexpectedly high; we determined that the skin sample had partially dried out during transport and repeated the test with fresh samples. This is a concrete example illustrating just how critical skin integrity is.

The table below provides a comparative summary of the key features of the OECD TG 431 and TG 430 guidelines.

Comparison of OECD TG 431 and TG 430 Skin Corrosion Test Guidelines
Feature OECD TG 431 (RhE) OECD TG 430 (TER)
Test System Three-dimensional RhE tissue models (human keratinocytes) Ex vivo bovine or human skin
Measurement Principle Cell viability (MTT assay, 50% threshold) Change in electrical resistance (TER value)
Application Time 3 minutes or 1 hour 24 hours (including resistance stabilization)
Suitable Test Substances Liquids, solids, pastes; water-soluble and water-insoluble substances Water-soluble substances; substances with extreme pH values
Challenges in Our Laboratory Uniform application on viscous substances; MTT interference Procurement of fresh skin; maintaining skin integrity

Advantages and Limitations of the RhE and TER Methods

The most significant advantage of both in vitro corrosion tests is that they fully comply with the “Replacement” principle of the 3Rs by completely eliminating the use of animals. Furthermore, these tests provide faster, more economical, and more reproducible results compared to in vivo tests. They simplify ethical review board approval processes and eliminate animal suffering. The importance of these alternatives is further heightened when evaluating highly corrosive substances, such as strong acids and bases, given the severe pain caused by in vivo tests.

The most significant advantage of TG 431 is its use of RhE models derived from human cells; this allows for the direct extrapolation of results to human biology. Furthermore, it is applicable regardless of the test substance’s physical form (liquid, solid, paste) and is also suitable for water-insoluble substances. The advantage of TG 430, on the other hand, is that it uses a real skin barrier and provides high accuracy, particularly for water-soluble substances and those with pH values at extreme ends of the spectrum. Since bovine skin is obtained as a byproduct of slaughterhouses, it does not pose any ethical concerns.

However, both tests have certain limitations. TG 431 cannot fully model dermal interactions because the RhE models consist only of the epidermal layer. Additionally, some test substances (e.g., strongly colored substances) may cause interference in the MTT test; in such cases, additional controls are required. TG 430, on the other hand, requires fresh skin samples, which can create logistical challenges and reproducibility issues. Furthermore, TG 430 is suitable only for water-soluble substances; TG 431 should be preferred for water-insoluble substances. Aware of these limitations, our laboratory customizes the testing strategy for each product and offers complementary analyses when necessary.

Conducting In Vitro Corrosion Tests in Our Laboratory

In our GLP-certified laboratory, we conduct corrosion tests covered by both OECD TG 431 and TG 430 in full compliance with international standards. For TG 431, we use validated RhE models (EpiSkin™, EpiDerm™, SkinEthic™); for TG 430, we source fresh bovine skin samples to perform the test. Our testing process begins with a comprehensive preliminary evaluation, during which the test substance’s physicochemical properties, pH value, solubility, and chemical structure are examined. Based on this information, the most appropriate test method is determined.

Test results are interpreted according to GHS criteria, and the substance is classified as “Skin Corrosive” (Category 1) or “Non-Corrosive.” Our reports include details on the test method, tissue model or skin sample, exposure duration, cell viability or resistance values, as well as negative and positive control results and an interpretation section. Comprehensive study reports compliant with the OECD template meet the requirements of EU REACH, the CLP Regulation, GHS, and other regulatory frameworks.

One of our laboratory’s key advantages is that we offer corrosion and irritation tests as part of an integrated strategy. A substance’s corrosion potential (TG 430 or TG 431) is first evaluated; if the substance is not corrosive, its irritation potential (TG 439) is then tested. This integrated approach provides efficiency in terms of both time and cost and generates a comprehensive data package for regulatory submissions.

Frequently Asked Questions

One of the most common questions we receive regarding the in vitro skin corrosion test is which test is appropriate for which substance. TG 431 is suitable for substances in liquid, solid, and paste forms, as well as water-insoluble substances. TG 430, on the other hand, is ideal for water-soluble substances and those with pH values at extreme ends of the scale. Our laboratory evaluates the properties of the test substance and recommends the most appropriate method.

We are also frequently asked whether an in vitro corrosion test is required for a substance with an extreme pH value. No. Substances with a pH ≤2 or ≥11.5 are classified directly as “Skin Corrosive” (Category 1) without applying OECD TG 430 or TG 431. This approach has been mandated by the OECD to prevent unnecessary testing.

It is also often asked whether in vitro corrosion test results can replace in vivo tests. Yes, validated TG 430 and TG 431 tests allow for corrosion classification without the need for in vivo testing. The OECD and EU REACH accept these in vitro methods as primary tests. However, if test results are inconclusive or if the regulatory authority specifically requests it, in vivo validation may be required.

Regarding the test duration, TG 431 typically yields results within 1–2 weeks; TG 430, however, may take 2–3 weeks due to the procurement of skin samples and resistance stabilization. Including reporting and quality assurance review, the total duration is 3–5 weeks. Finally, the question arises as to which regulatory submissions these tests can be used for. TG 430 and TG 431 reports are valid for EU REACH, the CLP Regulation, GHS classification, U.S. EPA FIFRA, and Turkish KKDIK requirements.

Skin corrosion is the most serious local toxic effect that chemical substances can cause, and accurately determining this effect forms the foundation of user safety. With our tests, which are fully compliant with OECD TG 431 and TG 430 standards, we evaluate the corrosion potential of your products according to the highest scientific standards and without the need for animal testing. Our GLP-certified laboratory, equipped with validated RhE models, fresh skin samples, and an experienced team, is your reliable partner for in vitro skin corrosion testing needs. To demonstrate your product’s skin safety, contact us.

EnglishenEnglishEnglish